Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Instagram Apocalypse 2013



Everyone knows that the Mayans may or may not have predicted that the world will end on December 21, 2012.  Experts are now saying that there is another major calamity awaiting right around the corner for those of us who survive on January 16, 2013.  That's when Instagram's new privacy policy will take effect.

There are a number of reasons why this isn't the end of the world.

The EFF is claiming that by including language in the "Rights" section of Instagram’s new Terms of Use, Instagram will now be able to sell your photos to other companies.  This is an accurate reading of the terms "transferable" and "sub-licensable" that are added to the license you grant Instagram in order for them to display their photos on the site.  This reading, however, discounts the rest of that sentence which says the photos you post are still restricted to whatever privacy settings you already have in place and that the use must comply with Instagram's privacy policy.

There will probably be herds of Zombies after the Mayan Apocalypse walking around with their smartphones, wondering if an equally undead corporation might use their pictures of brains for their own purposes.  Like when Virgin Mobile of Australia took pictures from a 16 year old’s Flickr stream to use on bus stops for its wireless phone marketing campaign.  It has happened, and  that scenario is not allowed by Flickr’s current Terms of Use…so there aren’t any guarantees even if the Terms of Use are perfect.

There is also another explanation for Instagram’s change.  The privacy policy has certain limited uses for what Instagram is allowed to do with your content.  In addition to requiring that they respect your privacy settings, the privacy policy says that in case of a merger, the content you upload might be a part of what is transferred to the new company.  The Terms of Use "transfer" language is very common in software contracts and is typically used to protect in the event the company is sold or acquired so that their customers can't run away kicking and screaming. 

Is Facebook considering selling off Instagram?  Maybe they just want to have their options open if the world does come to an end on Friday?

Perhaps they need the language in order to do what Facebook is already doing when they let you "Like" news articles and other pages on sites outside of Facebook.  (Please feel free to "like" and/or "share" this article.)  Or maybe they have a new feature or product up their sleeve that necessitated a change.

Or it could be that Facebook is just bringing Instagram's Terms of Use into line with Facebook's existing policy that uses the same "transferrable" and "sub-licensable" language.  That’s probably it.

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

What happens when a public company has your private data?


What happens when a public company has your private data?  It used to be that Facebook was owned and operated by a private citizen.  Sure it was fun to question his motives.  Those were the days.  Maybe it wouldn’t have changed if Facebook shares had started to skyrocket from the getgo, but they didn’t.  And now they have shareholders to think about.  So what happens to Privacy when Facebook shares drop like an anchor?  

The shareholders start to yank the leash.

This week, Facebook announced they will start allowing individuals under the age of 13 to join its site.  A bit of background here, most Internet companies have policies against catering to kids younger than 13, not because they care about the kids, but because they have to comply with a set of guidelines called the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act  or COPPA.  COPPA requires service providers to verify that they have their parent’s consent, usually by taking a credit card number or having their parents call a telephone number.
To sweeten the IPO, look at the changes they made in the final weeks before their IPO.  They announced a major change to their privacy policy.  They will now “retain data for as long as necessary to provide services to users and others”.  This is after FB was fined $138,000 in 2011 inIreland for keeping a deleted user’s data.

Now back to children under 13.  Zuckerberg was quoted in 2011 with saying that kids should be allowed on Facebook.  Not for selfish reasons, of course, but because he thinks that it could help with their education.  Because they can learn a lot from other students.  And why not allow kids on Facebook?  Lots of parents create accounts for their kids while they are still in the womb…like the Superbowl commercial for Google where the parents create an account and start emailing their child pictures and stories.

Lawmakers are highly concerned that Facebook is opening up to children under 13 to create a whole new market of potential advertises for themselves.  You can already sell targeted ads by age group, so why not start targeting kids with more sugar cereals and toys and movies.  Because maybe kids don’t watch so many commercials anymore.  Thanks TiVo!

Of course, Facebook also announced that they will allow their users to vote on the new change.  To be binding on the company, whatever the vote turns out, 30% of the users or 270 million people need to click.  US National voter turnout in 2010 was only about 37% and only 90 million people voted.  Only Facebook knows how many of their 900+ million users are very active on the site, my guess is that it is probably less than 50%, but it would be astounding that enough people would vote, for or against, the privacy policy changes.  So one might ask...is the vote just going through the motions?

Monday, April 30, 2012

Facebook "Likes" Not Protected Speech?

ArsTechnica has a great summary of the case of Bland v. Roberts, which has ruled that Facebook "Likes" are not protected speech under the 1st Amendment.  The case was decided in the Eastern District Court of Virginia, so it could be appealed a couple of times before hitting the Supreme Court...  There have been lots of other cases where something didn't have to actually constitute speech to be protected under the 1st Amendment, so it isn't clear if this case would stand if appealed.

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Why don’t Americans care about Privacy?

In my post from earlier this year, I commented on how Senator Leahy re-introduced his Personal Data Privacy Act…the same bill he has been submitted every year for the last 5 years. 5 months after the re-introduction of the bill this year, there is still no GOP support for Leahy’s Privacy bill.


By my count so far this year, there were 9 data privacy bills introduced into both houses of Congress. This may not sound like a ton, but is half the number of the bills introduced during the Health Care Reform debate of 2008. So it looks like 2011 won’t be the year we get a national data privacy law.


Why not? Do Americans not care about Privacy? Of course they do. Every state in America now has their own data privacy law. How often are their respective Attorney’s General enforcing those laws? Most of them don’t have private rights of action, so there isn’t any one else to enforce them. States probably wont enforce the laws unless they can collect some fines out of it, which means smaller infractions will get overlooked anyway. So Americans have some privacy, but not very much.


Facebook is at war with Privacy. In January of 2010, Facebook’s founder, Mark Zuckerberg pronounced that Privacy is dead. The EU Obviously cares. They’ve spent the last 30 years putting steroids into their Privacy laws. Max Screms, a European law student, is taking Facebook to task over their numerous violations of Irish Privacy laws. Although European members data privacy laws still differ, their push for privacy started with the OECD in 1980 and more recently the EU Data Protection Directive.


So why aren’t Americans more up in arms? Max Screms worries, “The KGB or the CIA never had 1200 pages [of information] on the average citizen.” But Facebook does.


Some theories about why American’s don’t care about Privacy:



  • We’re more worried about the economy – nope, the unemployment rate in Europe has been much worse for longer.

  • Most people haven’t read 1984 – that’s probably true…it’s never been made into an American movie with Brad Pitt.

  • We’re more worried about the stock market, the housing market, health care reform??? This is interesting…the Occupy Wall Street movement, along with the Tea Party, and the Iraq War Activists have been some of the few examples where Americans have been willing to take to the streets for a cause en mass in recent memory.

  • We’re more worried about Terrorism than the EU – I don’t think so. The Facebook case is going on in Ireland, and I think they’re slightly more sensitive to terrorism than we are.

  • What about Corporate Interests – some might say our politicians are bought and sold by corporations. While that may be a valid point, politicians everywhere suffer from the same temptations, and by all evidence, American politicians get in trouble a lot less than their European, Russian, or Asian counterparts.

  • Maybe we’re naturally voyeuristic? We are willing to trade our own privacy in order to invade other people’s privacy. This sounds pretty accurate to me.

  • Maybe we assume if it’s really a problem, then we can just sue somebody. Oh wait, all the so called ‘privacy’ legislation being thrown around doesn’t give individuals a private right of action against privacy infringers. Fines just go to state coffers and probably aren’t enough to deter bad behavior anyway. Remember CAN-SPAM? Of course you don’t.

  • Maybe Americans are just behind the curve? After all, Myspace fell apart, and that could have been an unconscious choice by the faceless public because Myspace felt less secure…from the viruses, to the unsolicited connections from weirdos, to how the apps felt like they gave away your information in a more overt way. Do we vote with our feet? Voting with one’s feet presumes that you have a meaningful choice…if you’re just voting between the lesser of two evils, then you end up voting for the more clean cut of two gangsters who doesn’t curse and swear while they rifle through your life.

  • Or maybe Americans do care about privacy. Maybe the ones that really care, haven’t bothered to join Facebook or have left. So why aren’t they up in arms? If they were, then they’d be in the spotlight, and that’s not really something they’re interested in. Why should they take a stand to protect you when you’re obviously okay with giving up your personal details? Also, this group of people tends to wear tin-foil hats.