The White House this week released a plan to stop state sponsored hacking, like the one uncovered by Mandiant this week, through the use of diplomatic pressure. The 72 page report details the measures that the White House is willing to use as leverage. The strategy stops short of threatening economic or other types of sanctions.
No word yet from the hackers on whether they will lay down their compilers. A more likely response will be that they install malware into the PDF of the report. Sorry if you already clicked the link. I can picture the hackers learning to say "Diplomatic Immunity" a la Lethal Weapon 2.
HackLaw is a blog dedicated to discussing the legal issues in information security and developments that may have an impack on information security law.
Friday, February 22, 2013
Wednesday, February 20, 2013
Privacy is Dead: Now Where's My Inheritance - Part 2
In Part 1 of my Post, Privacy is Dead, I estimated that giving up Privacy in exchange for a number of benefits could be worth as much as $10,000 per year to an individual. While this isn't pocket change for most of us, for someone making minimum wage, this might represent 6 months of work. Let's take a deeper dive in where that $10,000 number is coming from.
Privacy Property
Why should a company, either your phone company or a bank, be able to share information about you? Because it creates a new type of property…Privacy Property is the new Intellectual Property. Google and Facebook have both been very successful at leveraging this Privacy Property to create a new source of wealth. And we welcome it for the same reasons that we wanted credit scores. There are scores of new types of Privacy Property that have been created in the last 10 years, and some that have been made even more valuable.
Facebook’s Chief of Privacy was quoted as saying that they are working to get rid of surprises. That seems to address privacy issues…so long as people aren’t surprised by what they are sharing, then it’s okay. As long as we’re getting our Inheritance, we’re happy. Hopefully we don’t find ourselves cut out of the will.
Privacy Property
Why should a company, either your phone company or a bank, be able to share information about you? Because it creates a new type of property…Privacy Property is the new Intellectual Property. Google and Facebook have both been very successful at leveraging this Privacy Property to create a new source of wealth. And we welcome it for the same reasons that we wanted credit scores. There are scores of new types of Privacy Property that have been created in the last 10 years, and some that have been made even more valuable.
- Credit – $2,000/yr to $4,000/yr – Today, the average American has approximately $200,000 in debt between mortgages, cars, student loans, and credit cards. Just one percentage point of difference on a loan could mean thousands of dollars per year in value that this sharing of private information creates.
- Book Reading – $100/yr – Librarians have a long tradition of protecting what books their patrons are reading. They’ve fought and won to protect the FBI or other groups from being able to find out who checked out books like “Mein Kampf”. As it turns out, perhaps that fight was all for nothing. With eBooks, retailers like Amazon and Barnes and Noble have the ability to not just track what books you have read, but they can provide detailed demographics back to the publishers, who in turn can use this information to tailor books at their audiences. In addition, they can figure out things that were impossible before, like what pages or passages were most bookmarked, what chapter caused people to lose interest and stop reading.
- TV Viewing habits – $500/yr – Arthur C. Nielsen created a company starting in the 1950s that tracked what television programs their subscribers watched. Subscribers were paid for this information. Today, this information can be gained without special tracking equipment. TiVo has the ability to not only track what we watch, but how we watch it…which became especially clear when they reported that Janet Jackson’s wardrobe malfunction during the 2008 Super Bowl was the most replayed video ever.
- Driving History – $100/yr to $1,000/yr – For years, Insurance companies have used driving history to help underwrite their insurance practices. Today, they have begun using “black boxes” to track how their customers are driving, whether they stop or speed, where they drive and when they drive. Their customers love this, because they can save hundreds or thousands of dollars per year. Loss of privacy creates value.
- Shopping Habits – $1,000/yr – For years, advertisers have tried to figure out what makes a shopper tick. Now they don’t have to. Companies like Amazon can figure out what you will like before you know it.
- Video Rental – $500/yr – Your movie watching history is critical to figuring out what you’ll want to watch next. Netflix has come up with their own algorithms that can predict better than their competitors what movies you want to watch. If they know what you want, the more likely you are to buy it, and buy it from them. The next Step for Netflix and Hulu, Blockbuster, Amazon, and others is to let you tell your friends about the great movie you just watched…but to do that in an automated fashion, they need to get Congress to change the VPPA. Oh, wait, Congress just passed that in January of 2013! Welcome to the future!
- Location Information – $1,000/yr – Today, Google will customize your search results based on where you are, so you get results in your city, not just anywhere in the US. Your location information can be used to better target advertising to you. This was naturally the case when television advertisers bought airtime based on the region you lived in. Google already knows where you are generally based on your IP address, mobile technologies take this a step further.
- Change of Life Predictors – $500/yr – Today, Credit Card companies know enough about your daily habits that they can predict, for example, when you are going to get divorced or have children. Not that those two things are related. These major life events can have a large impact on your risk profile, perhaps reducing or increasing your credit rating profile.
- Health Records – $1,000/yr HIPAA was originally enacted, not because of Privacy concerns, but because there was a need to move from paper health records to electronic ones. Just like any other business, this was cost driven. Electronic insurance claims processing has helped reduce health care costs. Just imagine how much more expensive health care would be with only paper records. The future is complicated. Should individuals who smoke or drink have to pay more for health care? Your employer says yes!
- Free Stuff – $1,000/yr – Remember in the early 2000’s when you could get free Internet Access or even a free computer if you signed up for a service that would display a constant stream of advertising to you? It’s possible in the future that a clever company could provide you a cellular smart phone for free with no monthly fees. All you have to do is let it track your every move, pop up location based advertising wherever you go. Let it show you ads based on what you say in text messages just like how Google advertises in their mail. Sell your driving habits to insurance companies without the need for a black box.
Facebook’s Chief of Privacy was quoted as saying that they are working to get rid of surprises. That seems to address privacy issues…so long as people aren’t surprised by what they are sharing, then it’s okay. As long as we’re getting our Inheritance, we’re happy. Hopefully we don’t find ourselves cut out of the will.
Monday, February 18, 2013
Privacy is Dead: Now where's my Inheritance - Part 1
Privacy is Dead.
It’s not the first time you’ve heard this, surely. A private investigator, Sam Rambam was quoted as saying “Privacy is Dead – Get Over it” in 2006. In 2012, Huffing Post contributor Miles Feldman posed the question “Is Privacy Dead?”
If it is, then we’ve been collecting our inheritance without knowing it for years.
When did it die? It seemed to have contracted some terminal illness sometime around the same time that the computer was invented. It slipped away in the night somehow without anyone noticing. People worry about privacy related to the Internet, but this was only the first time we noticed that our attitudes about privacy were changing. There were two major events that most likely started this – the first was the Phone Book and the second was your credit rating.
When the telephone was first invented, people needed a way of reaching each other…in order to make the device useful, operators would connect two people to each other. This was a costly way of doing business, so phone companies published subscriber information in a “Book” so that subscribers could directly connect with one another without human intervention. In this way, we willingly gave up some of our privacy in order for the value that connection gave us. Phonebooks became a business model for phone companies – they began selling advertising space in their phone books and now make billions. You could get your privacy back by requesting an unlisted number, but this too had its price.
Before the early 1900s, when you needed credit to make a purchase, a man from the bank would go around and ask your friends, relatives, and neighbors what kind of person you were. Credit translated into character. It was the best we could do at the time. After WWII, people started needing more and more credit after coming back from a costly war. In 1970, the Fair Credit Reporting Act was enacted to offer some rules to govern this new model of collecting and distributing personal information. Now, banks could share your information with each other, which allowed them to know when someone had defaulted on or had excessive amounts of loans with other organizations. This reduced the risk of issuing a loan, which allowed banks to give loans at better rates. Again, giving up privacy created real value for an individual.
When you add it all up, my estimate is that the loss of Privacy, i.e. all the private information that we give up every day to do business actually has a significant tangible value. My estimate is that our Privacy Inheritance is worth as much as $10,000 or more per year. For most Americans, that’s like having a second part time job.
Click here to read Part 2 of this post.
It’s not the first time you’ve heard this, surely. A private investigator, Sam Rambam was quoted as saying “Privacy is Dead – Get Over it” in 2006. In 2012, Huffing Post contributor Miles Feldman posed the question “Is Privacy Dead?”
If it is, then we’ve been collecting our inheritance without knowing it for years.
When did it die? It seemed to have contracted some terminal illness sometime around the same time that the computer was invented. It slipped away in the night somehow without anyone noticing. People worry about privacy related to the Internet, but this was only the first time we noticed that our attitudes about privacy were changing. There were two major events that most likely started this – the first was the Phone Book and the second was your credit rating.
When the telephone was first invented, people needed a way of reaching each other…in order to make the device useful, operators would connect two people to each other. This was a costly way of doing business, so phone companies published subscriber information in a “Book” so that subscribers could directly connect with one another without human intervention. In this way, we willingly gave up some of our privacy in order for the value that connection gave us. Phonebooks became a business model for phone companies – they began selling advertising space in their phone books and now make billions. You could get your privacy back by requesting an unlisted number, but this too had its price.
Before the early 1900s, when you needed credit to make a purchase, a man from the bank would go around and ask your friends, relatives, and neighbors what kind of person you were. Credit translated into character. It was the best we could do at the time. After WWII, people started needing more and more credit after coming back from a costly war. In 1970, the Fair Credit Reporting Act was enacted to offer some rules to govern this new model of collecting and distributing personal information. Now, banks could share your information with each other, which allowed them to know when someone had defaulted on or had excessive amounts of loans with other organizations. This reduced the risk of issuing a loan, which allowed banks to give loans at better rates. Again, giving up privacy created real value for an individual.
When you add it all up, my estimate is that the loss of Privacy, i.e. all the private information that we give up every day to do business actually has a significant tangible value. My estimate is that our Privacy Inheritance is worth as much as $10,000 or more per year. For most Americans, that’s like having a second part time job.
Click here to read Part 2 of this post.
Tuesday, December 18, 2012
Instagram Apocalypse 2013
Everyone knows that the Mayans may or may not have predicted
that the world will end on December 21, 2012. Experts are now saying that
there is another
major calamity awaiting right around the corner for those of us who survive
on January 16, 2013. That's when Instagram's new privacy policy will take
effect.
There are a number of reasons why this isn't the end of the
world.
The
EFF is claiming that by including language in the "Rights"
section of Instagram’s new
Terms of Use, Instagram will now be able to sell your photos to other
companies. This is an accurate reading of the terms
"transferable" and "sub-licensable" that are added to the
license you grant Instagram in order for them to display their photos on the
site. This reading, however, discounts the rest of that sentence which
says the photos you post are still restricted to whatever privacy settings you
already have in place and that the use must comply with Instagram's
privacy policy.
There will probably be herds of Zombies after the Mayan
Apocalypse walking around with their smartphones, wondering if an equally
undead corporation might use their pictures of brains for their own purposes.
Like when Virgin Mobile of Australia took pictures from
a 16 year old’s Flickr stream to use on bus stops for its wireless phone
marketing campaign. It has happened, and that scenario is not
allowed by Flickr’s current Terms of Use…so there aren’t any guarantees even if
the Terms of Use are perfect.
There is also another explanation for Instagram’s
change. The privacy policy has certain limited uses for what Instagram is
allowed to do with your content. In addition to requiring that they
respect your privacy settings, the privacy policy says that in case of a
merger, the content you upload might be a part of what is transferred to the
new company. The Terms of Use "transfer" language is very
common in software contracts and is typically used to protect in the event the
company is sold or acquired so that their customers can't run away kicking and
screaming.
Is Facebook considering selling off Instagram? Maybe
they just want to have their options open if the world does come to an end on
Friday?
Perhaps they need the language in order to do what Facebook
is already doing when they let you "Like" news articles and other
pages on sites outside of Facebook. (Please feel free to "like" and/or "share"
this article.) Or maybe they have a new feature or product up their
sleeve that necessitated a change.
Or it could be that Facebook is just bringing Instagram's
Terms of Use into line with Facebook's
existing policy that uses the same "transferrable" and
"sub-licensable" language. That’s probably it.
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Safe Web Act Reauthorized
Some laws are permanently on the books. Other laws have a sunset date...like the Bush Era Tax cuts. Sunsets have become popular these days as a way of keeping Congress honest so they have to renew the laws if they think they worked out well.
The Safe Web Act was one of those laws. Safe Web was passed in 2006 and granted the FTC the ability to share online fraud related data with foreign law enforcement. In the last several years, the FTC has become the central clearinghouse in the US Federal government for all things identity theft related, so it's good to see this law renewed.
Read more about the bill at the Hillicon Valley blog:
http://thehill.com/blogs/hillicon-valley/technology/270943-obama-signs-safe-web-act-into-law
The only catch is that there's another sunset. This time it's 2020.
The Safe Web Act was one of those laws. Safe Web was passed in 2006 and granted the FTC the ability to share online fraud related data with foreign law enforcement. In the last several years, the FTC has become the central clearinghouse in the US Federal government for all things identity theft related, so it's good to see this law renewed.
Read more about the bill at the Hillicon Valley blog:
http://thehill.com/blogs/hillicon-valley/technology/270943-obama-signs-safe-web-act-into-law
The only catch is that there's another sunset. This time it's 2020.
Friday, November 30, 2012
Warrantless Wiretap-Dancing
Yesterday
the Senate Judiciary Committee voted to update a law, the Electronic
Communications Privacy Act, (ECPA), to require law enforcement to obtain a
warrant before conducting searches of people’s online communications, including
email, Facebook posts, Twitter updates, and documents stored online. The
full Senate is not expected to vote on the changes to the law until 2013. As
written the ECPA is somewhat ironically named, since it currently allows law
enforcement to view any data stored online for more than six months without a
warrant.
Online privacy is good, right? Which means warrantless
searches are bad? There is a lot of contention on the issue. Law
Enforcement’s chief argument is that the ECPA has been in place for 26 years,
and nothing has gone wrong. Privacy groups argue that the Internet is a
different place than it was 25 years ago, so the law should be updated to
reflect how people use it today. Senator Leahey’s bill also
weakens the privacy of video viewing history, to the benefit of companies
like Hulu and Netflix, so overall any benefit to online privacy may be a wash.
Congress is examining these issues at the same time that an FBI
investigation went to the heart of these issues. The
investigation into the affair between CIA Chief David Petraeus and his
biographer, Paula Broadwell, presumably was done using some amount of
warrantless wiretapping to gather emails related to the affair and the
harassment of Jill Kelly by Broadwell. This investigation will be at the
forefront of the minds of the Congress when they take up the bill next year.
CNET last week discovered
an alternate version of the amendment last week that would have instead
expanded warrantless access to multiple types of online communications of
private citizens, from email to Facebook posts, to 22 different federal
agencies. This would have been a reversal from Leahy’s earlier position,
and may just have been a part of negotiations between the two sides.
Despite pressure from multiple Law Enforcement groups, Leahy
released a statement denying that CNET’s reports were accurate.
Barriers
Senator Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), is the ranking Republican on
the Senate Judiciary Committee. Grassley has expressed Law Enforcement’s
perspective that creating new barriers for wiretaps could hamper
investigations. At least one amendment to the proposed legislation is
expected that would create an exception to the warrant process for cases
involving kidnapping, child pornography or violent crimes against women.
This comes after a Federal
Appeals court okayed Warrantless Wiretapping in August. A three judge
panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals wrote
in their decision that “This case effectively brings to an end the plaintiffs’
ongoing attempts to hold the Executive branch responsible for intercepting
telephone conversations without judicial authorization.” The case
involved two American attorneys who were spied on without warrants as a part of
President George W. Bush’s secret terrorist surveillance program.
The case hinged on the issue of Sovereign Immunity. Even
though the United States was breaching its own wiretapping laws, the court
reasoned, the plaintiffs could not bring suit against the government for the
collection of the information itself. The court did leave room for the
plaintiffs to bring suit against the government if the information were used in
some way. The proposed changes to the ECPA wouldn’t affect the Sovereign
Immunity issue, which means citizens still have no real recourse if the
government doesn’t follow its own rules.
Not so simple?
It’s not surprising that wiretapping has increased as Law
Enforcement has evolved along with the digital age. The surprising part
is that a solution has not come along that helps streamline the warrant
requesting process. The intention behind a warrant isn’t to slow down the
searching process, or even to discourage it, but to ensure that a member of
another branch of government is available to ensure probable cause exists for
the search. According to the ACLU, warrantless
wiretapping has increased over 600% in the last 10 years. If this
continues, by 2020, the Justice Department may request over 100,000 warrantless
wiretaps. I think a long term question should be whether the already
overburdened court system can handle even more requests in a timely fashion.
No one is saying that the increase in wiretapping is the result
of more crime. Most crime statistics show that over the last decade,
crime rates are down. Why more wiretaps, then? Wiretaps represent
the way our world has changed to be more data driven. There is a longer
paper trail than there used to be, so Law Enforcement has to follow it.
Thursday, July 26, 2012
Controversial Cybersecurity Act Vote Coming Soon?
This week, House Majority Leader Harry Reid hopes to finally bring
the long awaited Cybersecurity Act of 2012 to the floor for debate.
Senator Joe Lieberman and the four co-sponsors of the Cybersecurity Act introduced a revised version last week,
which they indicate incorporates extensive negotiations with the bill’s
opponents. The Hill’s Technology Blog reports that Senators
Rockefeller and Feinstein are reaching out to key technology CEOs to help lend their support to the bill.
This is great, because if the bill doesn’t get voted on soon, it won’t happen this year. President Obama has weighed in as well. The President wrote a rare op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal to boost support. He writes, “The American people deserve to know that companies running our critical infrastructure meet basic, commonsense cybersecurity standards, just as they already meet other security requirements.”
This is in response to the bill’s critics who have stated that they would be concerned about the costs to businesses that would be imposed by the new law. John McCain’s bill, in contrast, focuses on strengthening the government’s Cybersecurity, but stops short of mandating that businesses do the same.
All this should be read in light of the larger Cyber conflict that is currently going on. New York Times writer David Sanger wrote last month that an inside source had confirmed what many had suspected, that the Obama administration had ordered a cyber attack against Iranian enrichment facilities.
Maybe this was a good thing. There was no loss of life that we know of, compared to a conventional military strike against Iranian facilities. A Cyber retaliation from the Iranians or their allies would have also been limited to computer infrastructure.
But the new Cybersecurity bill needs to be read in light of the fact that the US government dropped the most sophisticated Cyberweapon on the world that we have ever seen. It’s been analyzed and perhaps reproduced by other countries. And unlike a physical war where proximity to a conflict means greater risk, businesses are on the front lines of a Cyber conflict. At a psychological level, most businesses don’t have the same outlook that a business in a war torn country might perceive their situation.
The reality of Cybersecurity in America is that it’s not just stolen identity that businesses need to worry about. in November of 2011, for the first time, Robert Bryant, U.S. National Counterintelligence Executive released a report naming China as the world’s leading source of economic espionage, with Russia coming in a close second. The reality is that by attacking an economy is the equivalent of holding a government hostage, as the Russians did against Georgian banks in 2008.
Cybersecurity laws need to play catch up to the current state of the world where a rogue nation like Iran or North Korea with nothing to lose economically could lanuch a terrorist like attack against small or medium sized businesses with very weak defenses and wreak havoc. Unfortunately, the news today indicates that the bill is being fought on mostly partisan lines despite months of compromise that went into the new bill. Senator McCain wants to delay the bill and Heritage Action, a conservative advocacy group related to the Heritage Foundation indicated it will track lawmakers votes on their key vote scorecard.
This is great, because if the bill doesn’t get voted on soon, it won’t happen this year. President Obama has weighed in as well. The President wrote a rare op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal to boost support. He writes, “The American people deserve to know that companies running our critical infrastructure meet basic, commonsense cybersecurity standards, just as they already meet other security requirements.”
This is in response to the bill’s critics who have stated that they would be concerned about the costs to businesses that would be imposed by the new law. John McCain’s bill, in contrast, focuses on strengthening the government’s Cybersecurity, but stops short of mandating that businesses do the same.
All this should be read in light of the larger Cyber conflict that is currently going on. New York Times writer David Sanger wrote last month that an inside source had confirmed what many had suspected, that the Obama administration had ordered a cyber attack against Iranian enrichment facilities.
Maybe this was a good thing. There was no loss of life that we know of, compared to a conventional military strike against Iranian facilities. A Cyber retaliation from the Iranians or their allies would have also been limited to computer infrastructure.
But the new Cybersecurity bill needs to be read in light of the fact that the US government dropped the most sophisticated Cyberweapon on the world that we have ever seen. It’s been analyzed and perhaps reproduced by other countries. And unlike a physical war where proximity to a conflict means greater risk, businesses are on the front lines of a Cyber conflict. At a psychological level, most businesses don’t have the same outlook that a business in a war torn country might perceive their situation.
The reality of Cybersecurity in America is that it’s not just stolen identity that businesses need to worry about. in November of 2011, for the first time, Robert Bryant, U.S. National Counterintelligence Executive released a report naming China as the world’s leading source of economic espionage, with Russia coming in a close second. The reality is that by attacking an economy is the equivalent of holding a government hostage, as the Russians did against Georgian banks in 2008.
Cybersecurity laws need to play catch up to the current state of the world where a rogue nation like Iran or North Korea with nothing to lose economically could lanuch a terrorist like attack against small or medium sized businesses with very weak defenses and wreak havoc. Unfortunately, the news today indicates that the bill is being fought on mostly partisan lines despite months of compromise that went into the new bill. Senator McCain wants to delay the bill and Heritage Action, a conservative advocacy group related to the Heritage Foundation indicated it will track lawmakers votes on their key vote scorecard.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)