Wednesday, July 6, 2011

What has Al Franken done for me lately, Part 2

Last week, the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation held a hearing on Privacy and Information Security. Senator Rockefeller made a point of emphasizing his committee’s jurisdiction over privacy and data security issues. I think this statement alone shows a rift in the Senate’s perspective on Information Security in light of the newly formed subcommittee on Privacy on the Senate Judiciary Committee. I really hope that posturing and territorialism doesn’t hold up any new legislation this year, but it looks like it will.


Senator Toomey (R-PA) wanted to draw a distinction between privacy and security while bringing up the need for a cost-benefit analysis for the proposed regulations (read between the lines, changes to Privacy laws at least won’t be happening anytime soon).


From the perspective of business, all the legislation proposed this year needs to do is to set a national standard for data breaches that preempts state law so that there is one standard to follow rather than 46 different rules based on who your customers are and where they live. From the perspective of the states, they want a law that allows them to more easily sue offenders, thereby protecting their residents, and generating a new revenue source. States also don’t want the penalties to be too harsh for fear of appearing anti-business.


Most likely, any new data breach law will mirror HIPAA/HITECH. HIPAA has two types of penalties – penalties for non-compliance and penalties for wrongful disclosure. For HIPAA, penalties range from fines of $100 per violation for non-compliance, capped at $25,000 . For a wrongful disclosure, penalties can range from $50,000 to $250,000 and may include a prison sentence depending on the crime. All of the new legislation proposed this year has substantially higher penalties.


So what makes health related financial crime better or worse than SSN theft, for example? Have efforts to keep patient data cost Doctors and Hospitals money? Has HIPAA put healthcare out of business? Okay, bad example given the rising costs of healthcare, but you get the picture.


So what should Al Franken do next? Force companies to make their default settings completely private? Require background checks for companies that have access consumer information? Push for a Do-Not Track mechanism built into the web?

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

War Powers Resolution and Cyberwar

If you've been following the war in Libya and the Obama's report to Congress in June, you'll know that the administration is claiming that our military actions in Libya are not covered under the War Powers Resolution which would require them to be terminated after 60 days. To get around this window, there must be an authorization for the use of military force by Congress or a declaration of war.

The reasoning in the White House report is basically that since the action in Libya involves drones, no soldiers are being put in danger, so the War Powers Resolution doesn't apply. The reasoning also follows that we are acting in Libya under limited circumstances, only going after specific targets.

What does this have to do with Information Security you ask? Since Clinton ignored the Resolution in 1999, and other presidents have argued that the War Powers Resolution is unconstitutional, the conspiracy theorist in me wonders if the intent in this report wasn't to set a precedent in order for future actions to follow the same model. It seems to me that the same reasoning could be applied to Cyberwarfare. Soldier/Hackers are essentially the same as drone pilots. Cyberwar, if such a thing ever happens, will also most likely be fought in small theaters and in limited circumstances...not an all out world Cyberwar. Cyberwar actions would by definition also only be directed against specific types of infrastructure.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

What has Al Franken done for me lately, Part 1

In February of this year, the Senate Judiciary Committee voted to form a new sub-committee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law. They chose my favorite Senator, Al Franken to chair the new group. After I heard about this new committee’s formation back in February (feb 14), they kinda went radio silent for a few months, presumably putting their noses to the grindstone to come up with something brilliant. So what has Al Franken done for us lately?

On June 17th, Senator Franken introduced his Location Privacy Protection Act, which is probably just a gut reaction to Apple and Google Android’s ability to track where you’ve been, either inadvertently or overtly through compromised apps. This is great for privacy (if it ever gets passed), but most likely the two companies (Apple and Google) will clear up their vunlerabilities long before any legislation gets passed.

The real question is, Why? The supreme court this year will consider whether warrantless GPS tracking by the FBI is okay. The Justice department is arguing that “a person has no reasonable expectation of privacy in his movements from one place to another,”. If law enforcement is able to monitor citizens in this way, then why take the same information away from individuals who might want to see where their kids or spouse have been? Are we really concerned that hackers will want to know where we’ve been? Or are we worried that stalkers could use the info? That advertisers will be able to better market products to us based on our travel habits? Why should the government get a free pass when Facebook is getting beat up over releasing impersonal statistical data to advertisers?

So what about current laws on the books that protect Privacy, like HIPAA? This begs the question of whether health records are any more or less important than other types of personal information, like GPS tracking. The majority of crime that HIPAA attempts to prevent isn’t someone shouting from a rooftop that someone has an embarrassing rash or STD. HIPAA attempts to prevent financial crimes, which is exactly what SAFE Data and the Privacy Bill of Rights are about…They’re not about Privacy at all.

Now, this brings us back to what Al Franken has done for us lately. Is the Privacy sub-committee just an Orwellian attempt at naming a group that is out to protect the opposite of Privacy? After all, why should I care if my identity is stolen if the FTC limits my direct damages to $50? From studies, we know that indirect damages are higher, maybe $250. But the real damages are to companies, which pass along the costs to consumers.

Do we even care about Privacy anymore? If the answer is, "Only when it hurts us not to" then maybe we should be revising our notions of Privacy just as quickly as the technology evolves our ability to subvert it.

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

2011 US Information Security Related Measures

So far, in the first 6 months of 2011, there have been 9 different Information Security related proposals put forward by different Senators that would create new laws or reform existing ones.

February 20 2011 – Rep. Rush (D-Ill) reintroduces BEST PRACTICES Act

April 7 – SEC Regulation S-P mandates that financial firms safeguard confidential info

April 12, 2011 – Senators Kerry and McCain introduce Privacy Bill of Rights

April 13,2011 – Stearns introduces Consumer Privacy Protection Act of 2011

May 9, 2011 – Rockefeller Introduces Do-Not-Track Online Act of 2011

May 12, 2011 – White House Proposes Cybersecurity Legislation

June 7, 2011 – Senator Leahy reintroduces Personal Data Privacy and Security Act of 2011

June 13 2011 – SAFE Data Act

June 15 2011 – Location Privacy Protection Act

By my count, in 2009, there were approximately 18 different Health Care Proposals in 2009 before the House and Senate both adopted their own proposals. Comparing such a hotly debated and controversial issue, it seems difficult to accept that there is such a lack of consensus on what the next steps are or should be for Information Security legislation at the Federal Level. With the dramatic increase in hacking related incidents since the Sony DDOS and subsequent compromise, it seems likely that other groups will add their proposals to the mix.

Does this mean that the time is right for legislation to finally be passed? Does this mean that the different interest groups will begin working together? Does this mean that there is a lack of understanding of the issues and that further inaction can be expected until this is a larger issue with constituents? The issue with any legislation will be that it is difficult to mandate how a particular industry or company implements security in their environment. The Credit Card industry has been very successful in coming up with their own design, but typically this is one one part of a whole company's structure, and as we saw with Sony and more recently Citigroup, even big companies have trouble being compliant.

Whatever it does mean, it is still a very positive thing that so many individuals are putting their ideas forward. It may be that multiple laws could be passed, each on their own or all of these proposals could be refined down to one larger law.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Senator Leahy Introduces the Personal Data Privacy and Security Act of 2011

According to Senator Leahy's website, the Personal Data Privacy and Security Act would:

•Increasing criminal penalties for identity theft involving electronic personal data and making it a crime to intentionally or willfully conceal a security breach involving personal data;

•Giving individuals access to, and the opportunity to correct, any personal information held by commercial data brokers;

•Requiring entities that maintain personal data to establish internal policies that protect the personal data of Americans;

•Requiring entities that maintain personal data to give notice to individuals and law enforcement when they experience a breach involving sensitive personal data; and

•Requiring the government to establish rules protecting privacy and security when it uses information from commercial data brokers, to conduct audits of government contracts with data brokers and impose penalties on government contractors that fail to meet data privacy and security requirements.

The Senator has introduced this act several times before. Interestingly, they didn’t bother to change the stats from 9,300,000 victims of computer fraud (from the original version in 2007). The actual number for 2010 would have been more like 16,167,542 as reported by the Identity Theft Resource Center.

The only major change to the act since 2007 is the inclusion of section 103 which, in summary, changes the federal laws for computer fraud to include conspiracy to commit computer fraud. The most interesting part of this bill is that it makes the concealment of a breach a felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison.

Also, just like in the Privacy Bill of Rights and the Do-Not-Track acts previously discussed, this act imposes limitations on Civil Actions by the Attorneys General for states. In this case, the states are limited to $5,000 per day up to $500,000. This act does not specify whether this is a per-state limitation or whether as a whole this is a limitation for all of the states collectively. If so this particular legislation is definitely a step backward from the other two proposals enacted earlier this year. I’m still not certain whether it would be better to consolidate the three bills, or whether portions of the three bills could stand on their own. Will this be the year some legislation is finally enacted? Certainly there has been a lot of hacking so far in 2011, but it remains to be seen how much legislation can be done in the remainder of this year.

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Market Forces in Identity Theft

There can be real economic damages to an individual who is the victim of identity theft. The FTC has ruled that it is the individual’s responsibility to check their credit card statements for unauthorized statements. If a victim of credit card theft, for example, notifies the credit card company within 60 days of receipt of the statement, then the consumer’s liability is limited to $50.

Much of the literature on identity theft assumes that the value of an online identity has a fixed price. Say $.10 for an email password. $20 for a credit card number, etc. What this fails to take into account is that there is both supply and demand. Demand, most likely, is fixed. There are only so many possible 'fences' for stolen data. When a breach like TJ Max, Heartland, or Sony happens, the supply of stolen identities goes up by an order of magnitude while the demand remains the same. With this assumption, it is likely that the value of an online identity also goes down by an order of magnitude.

Maybe this is good for identity theft overall. What it could do is lower the risk/reward quotient for future identity thieves. If they knock over a small credit card merchant and only get 10,000 credit card numbers...then they may only be able to make 1/10th of what they would have before, while the risk of getting caught remains the same. Economically speaking, this might actually help deter future identity theft.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

“Do-not-track Online Act of 2011”

This month, Senate Commerce Chairman Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.) introduced the “Do-not-track Online Act of 2011”.

Some interesting highlights from the proposed bill: there would be a fine of up to $16,000 per day that you are in violation with a maximum of $15,000,000 in civil damages available for all civil actions under the bill. The $16,000 maximum is on a per state basis. That means that a vendor could have been exposing your personal information for 19 days before they hit the ceiling.

While that’s a big number, it is relatively low compared to the damages that could be done. Credit monitoring alone for a breach of a million accounts could meet that number. It also removes the incentive to address a breach after the 19th day because there would be no further penalty. A company like Facebook, who has been under enormous pressure to protect the privacy of its users for years, wouldn’t be concerned at all with such a low penalty. (At that point, doesn’t it become a $15 million license to violate privacy?)

This is an improvement, however, over the Privacy Bill of Rights introduced earlier this year by Senators Kerry and McCain. Their bill contained a very similar section, but the limit was $16,500 per day but capped at only $3 million.

I think if there is any privacy benefit to this rule, it would be that at least there was some stigma associated with a particular exposure, which might have a greater sting for companies like Facebook.